Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Review: Kappa Edger from Gerber Coburn

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Review: Kappa Edger from Gerber Coburn

    Product: Kappa Edger w \ 3-D Tracer\ Auto Blocker
    Vendor: Gerber Coburn
    Category: Lab Tools/Equipment
    Reviewer: Sean

    Ratings:
    Quality:
    Ease of use:
    Customer service of the manufacturer or distributor:
    Value:
    Overall:

    Review:
    First off I should point out that the price is for both the edger and tracer\auto blocker. I gave this piece of equipment very high marks for it’s initial learning curve and so far…. reliability. Sales rep was in charge of delivery and setup. Company has a recommended calibration interval of once a month; this has been done, even though there has been no apparent need to. Edger can be ordered with different wheel options, glass/plastic-poly/polish. Has auto groove for rimless, as well as safety bevels front/back (all of these options can be user defined i.e. depth of groove and degree of bevel with 4 different user assigned presets each for preference. On board software has been updated since gamma series resolving issues with e-line’s. Also equipped with bar code scanners for both the blocker and edger with an initial memory of 200 orders, which can be upgraded to 400. To this day I’m impressed with the accuracy of this machine. As for company’s assumption that “Just about anyone can run this equipment” is a little off the mark. You need to have the concept of what you are doing and what you are trying to achieve. In short, to think just pushing a series of buttons will result in a perfect pair of glasses should not be the foundation to have a person start working with this piece of machinery.In fact the only thing you will achieve is damaging the machine, as the equipment does have flaws when it comes to inexperience (this can result on any piece of optical equipment mind you). Users should have a good degree of knowledge in the lab. Not unless you would like someone to start edging crown glass on the poly wheel. Yes the machine is hi tech…….but we do have a human equation to work with here. In the hands of someone with experience it is capable of producing an excellent product. I have personally cut lenses from +13.00D to –15.00D along with Bi-Concaves, Aspheric Lenticular’s, Myodisks ……….just to name a few. To consider buying this equipment, I would have to say your work volume should be at least 15 to20 orders per day to be beneficial /cost effective, as the Kappa was made and designed for high output labs. On a final note the Kappa comes fully designed to interface with their line of surfacing equipment as well.

  • #2
    Years ago.....

    Sean,

    Years ago I worked for a company that distributed Briot edgers. Their patternless originally priced at about 21 K. We figured that if you did 5 jobs a day it would pay for itself. That was when finishing was about $5 per job. The average finish job now is about $8.If you extrapolate 15 jobs X $8 X25 days in a month you come up with 3K. You'd have the machine paid for in 10 months!

    Why do you think you would need 15 to 20 jobs a day to make it feasable.

    Great Review!

    hj
    "Always laugh when you can. It is a cheap medicine"
    Lord Byron

    Take a photo tour of Cape Cod and the Islands!
    www.capecodphotoalbum.com

    Comment


    • #3
      Harry,
      15/20 jobs a day on average..........what about those days when you do nothing but repairs? I.E. last week with the snow storm.......4 day's straight not a customer/lab job to be had. These are the things that have to be considered when you go out and spend 30,000.00 dollars on just one piece equipment. I think that if everyone here could be be guaranteed 15-25 jobs per day Coburn would sell even more of them. Purchasing one with the figures you mentioned in your above post would seem feasible but more than likely this would not be the case. And i would not recommend purely relying on such a figure to justify going out and buying one.

      Comment


      • #4
        Can't Wait..............

        Sean

        My machine is on order to be delivered in 2 weeks I will be raplacing a Optronics Horizon III..:D We have the Kappa in one of our other stores and I have run a few jobs on it with no formal training;) ..........I have pushed the HIII to its limits and I can not wait to get my hands on the Kappa and see what she can really do..........

        I enjoyed your review and already know that you are so correct on all your points......

        Sincerely
        Mikol
        :cheers: :cheers:

        Comment


        • #5
          Mikol,
          Be sure to come back here and let me know what you think,after you have had a bit to really put it to the test:D The kappa actually retired three edgers in the lab.....a Briot,Daytona and a Profile M. Did you order it with or without the glass wheel?

          Comment


          • #6
            I had dealt with Coburn many years ago before they were bought by Gerber.
            I loved the products, reps and tech assistance was great.
            I purchased a pricey edger from them with extended coverage. The edger was a lemon.
            I needed to puchase extended coverage every year for three years, just to keep the machine running, until Gerber Coburn refused to honor another warranty period. In the fourth year we had to scrap the edger.
            With the service charge on phone calls and the worst machine I had in 22 years , I am still open to hearing about quality equipment.
            I hope you feel the same after the warranty period is over.
            Joseph Felker
            AllentownOptical.com

            Comment


            • #7
              Did I understand you correctly?

              jofelk,
              Did I understand you correctly? You bought a machine from Coburn (before the merger) and you renewed a warantee on that machine for 3 years (which made it a total of 4), and you expected the new company to renew that warantee for a fifth year on a machine they did not manufacture?

              I just want to be clear on what your complaint is.

              tx harry j
              "Always laugh when you can. It is a cheap medicine"
              Lord Byron

              Take a photo tour of Cape Cod and the Islands!
              www.capecodphotoalbum.com

              Comment


              • #8
                Sorry about my time line. I usually review this site first thing in the morning and the thoughts are sometimes scattered.
                I had bought equipment (edgers, generators, reclaims, etc.) from Coburn years ago (15-20) and was very happy wirh them.
                After they were bought by Gerber I purchased the pricey edger. It was a warranty we purchased each year for a total of three years.
                I do not want this forum to be my retribution against Gerber Coburn. This was my experience with their equipment and service. Like I said in my previous thread, I am always glad to hear about quality equipment that makes our job simpler and more pofitable.
                Good luck with the edger!
                Joseph Felker
                AllentownOptical.com

                Comment


                • #9
                  Mikol, I started out in '93 with the Briot patternless, then in '96 went to the Horizon III, and in 2001 went to the Horizon 6E, big improvements; still liked the "dry cut" units better. but like most things these days, with drill mounts, etc, you best have some finish lab skills beyond pushing a button on the edger. Sean, there is more than the cost saving factor to in-house edging; it's a matter of value added service too. I've never had a problem with the paying for it; seems like we've always had a flucuating business loan, and when we pruchased a new edger, or other equipment, we just added it to our existing note, and kept the payment the same, just added time, which is eternal, and there are some buyiny benefits to paying the seller cash on delivery.

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Texas Ranger said: Sean, there is more than the cost saving factor to in-house edging; it's a matter of value added service too. I've never had a problem with the paying for it; seems like we've always had a flucuating business loan, and when we pruchased a new edger, or other equipment, we just added it to our existing note, and kept the payment the same, just added time, which is eternal, and there are some buyiny benefits to paying the seller cash on delivery.
                    Taxas Ranger,
                    Point well taken,good info.

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Kappa

                      Sean,

                      I got the machine installed yesterday and ran 17 jobs the first day. What a joy! I was not to impressed with the speed but I will take the quality of the finished job in exchange. I only did rimless and bevel jobs I will be in the office tomorrow and see how well the groover works. We carry the Lindberg collections and I can't wait to make lenses for the RIM & STRIP collections.

                      The barcode system is really great I can just tell you now that that feature will save us a lot of headaches.....we do one hour jobs and sometimes the HIII would be all loaded and ready to cut and a customer walks in and mixes up the order of the trays:angry:

                      A great new toy , but I will keep my HIII set up and at the ready.

                      cheers
                      Mikol
                      :cheers: :cheers:

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Gospel according to Sean is

                        Mikol,
                        Gospel according to Sean is: you won't need it!
                        "Always laugh when you can. It is a cheap medicine"
                        Lord Byron

                        Take a photo tour of Cape Cod and the Islands!
                        www.capecodphotoalbum.com

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Is this their top of the line edger or they offer something even better?

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            LENNY said:
                            Is this their top of the line edger or they offer something even better?
                            Lenny,
                            Gerber/Coburn just introduced a new version called the Kappa SP.

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Kappa

                              There's the Titan, but that's intended for high-production environments (i.e., constant-duty, and/or automated).


                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X